🥪 Old Moon Deli and Pies – A quirky downtown Galveston favorite where handcrafted sandwiches and decadent pies meet Victorian charm. Housed in a historic two-story building with cozy upstairs seating and eclectic decor, this artist-owned deli serves up bold flavors, vegan-friendly options, and a rotating pie case that locals rave about.

🥪 Old Moon Deli and Pies

📍 Address:
408 23rd St
Galveston, TX 77550

📞 Phone:
(409) 497-4446

⏰ Hours:
Sun–Thu: 11 AM – 5 PM
Fri–Sat: 11 AM – 7 PM

🌐 Website:
oldmoondeliandpies.com

📍 Neighborhood:
Tremont Avenue & 23rd Street • Downtown Galveston

🚗 Parking:
Free off-street parking available

♿ Accessibility:
Wheelchair entrance • Vegan, vegetarian & gluten-free options • Digital payments accepted

🪑 Features:
Indoor seating • Upstairs gallery lounge • Credit cards • Highchairs
Table service • Takeout • Delivery via DoorDash & Uber Eats
Kid-friendly • Not pet-friendly

📌 Quick Facts

💵 Price Range:
Budget-Friendly Dining

💲 Avg. Cost:
$10–$18 (sandwich, drink & dessert)

⭐ Avg. Rating:
4.7/5 (240+ reviews)

🍽️ Cuisine:
American • Café • Deli • Hidden Gem

🪑 Style:
Eclectic sandwich shop • Cozy & artsy • Gallery-style seating

📦 Service:
Walk-ins • Takeout • Delivery via DoorDash & Uber Eats

🍽️ Dish of the Day:

🌟 Top Dishes:

  • Monte Cristo with Raspberry Jam
  • Island Time Sandwich with Jerk Chicken & Pineapple
  • Reuben & Hot Pastrami Sandwich
  • Turkey Club with Fig Spread
  • Black Bean Burger & Vegan Dawg
  • Dark Chocolate Raspberry Pie & Key Lime Pie

👍 Locals Recommend:
Monte Cristo & Raspberry Pie

🌊 Vibe:
Whimsical and welcoming • Great for lunch dates • Downtown deli delight

Disclaimer: Info based on public sources. Confirm details with the restaurant before visiting.

Take a peek

Galveston County
Author: Galveston County

We spotlight trusted businesses across hospitality, real estate, dining, services, and more — with a focus on accuracy, authenticity, and local pride. Every listing is carefully reviewed, and every feature is designed to connect residents and visitors with the best our island has to offer.

Who we are: We’re proud locals dedicated to showcasing Galveston’s culinary culture through a thoughtfully curated Dining Guide. Whether you’re craving coastal flavors, comfort food, or hidden neighborhood gems, our listings are built with accuracy, charm, and community spirit. Eat well. Explore often. And by all means, get the desert!

Find us on:

💰 How We Determine a Restaurant’s Price Range

The pricing labels in this guide (like “Budget-Friendly,” “Mid-Range Dining,” and “Upscale Dining”) are typically based on estimated cost per person for a typical meal (entrée, drink, appetizer or dessert), combined with other cues like menu offerings, ambiance, service style, and venue reputation. Here’s a framework you can use to get an idea:

💵 Price Label – based on average ticket per person

Budget-Friendly – Under $15–$20 – Cafes, casual eateries, quick service

Mid-Range Dining$20–$35 – Sit-down restaurants, bars, grills, family spots

Upscale Dining – $35–$60+ – Steakhouses, seafood joints, refined venues

Fine Dining – $60–$100+ – Chef-driven menus, dress codes, premium plating

We also factor in:

Audience cues: If most diners are celebrating anniversaries, that’s a signal.

Ingredients: Lobster, dry-aged steak, imported wine — likely upscale.

Ambiance: White linens and custom lighting vs. beach shack vibes.

Service: Table service with sommeliers or tasting menus implies fine dining.

Some folks idea of “low-budget” or “Upscale” may be different than other folks. So if you see a buffet in a building about to fall apart and it says “upscale”, don’t fret! It just means the average ticket per person ticks the upscale box.

⭐ How We Rate Restaurants

We blend public reviews from places like Google, Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Restaurantji into one fair and balanced score. We look at overall rating, number of reviews, and recurring themes — whether folks are hyping the shrimp tacos or praising the warm service. More reviews means more confidence, but we also listen closely to what locals are loving (or not) as well.

We also have our own review section at the end of each listing, which you are welcome to provide feedback. We just prefer to average the ratings across all platforms for a more accurate overview. Think of it as a community-powered scorecard. (I know, we are a little nerdy, but it works)!

📬 Updates, Questions, Feedback — Wanna Talk About Grandpa’s Dinner Table Tangents?

Whatever’s on your mind — whether it’s fine-tuning a restaurant detail or venting about wildly mistimed family stories — we’re here for it. Drop us a message anytime.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

One-Time
Monthly
Yearly

❤️ Love what we’re doing? Fuel our journey with a donation—your support keeps Galveston’s most up-to-date dining insights rolling!

❤️ Love what we’re doing? Fuel our journey with a donation—your support keeps Galveston’s most up-to-date dining insights rolling!

❤️ Love what we’re doing? Fuel our journey with a donation—your support keeps Galveston’s most up-to-date dining insights rolling!

Choose an amount

$5.00
$15.00
$100.00
$5.00
$15.00
$100.00
$5.00
$15.00
$100.00

Or enter a custom amount

$

Your contribution is appreciated.

Your contribution is appreciated.

Your contribution is appreciated.

DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearly


Discover more from Galveston Dining Guide

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading